These Mistakes Cut Your Cold Email Replies in Half

I was on a strategy call with an agency founder who was stuck.

They’d sent 300+ cold emails.

They followed what they thought were the right steps:

• Multiple follow-ups

• Clear ICP research

• Data-backed problem statements

• Well-structured copy

But the results told a different story:

→ 20% open rate (should be 50%+)

→ No meaningful replies

→ Zero calls booked

They asked if I’d take a look.

I’ve seen this pattern too often not to say yes.

The First Red Flag: Low Open Rates

When I opened their sequence, one issue jumped out immediately.

Their subject lines were too long.

It’s a small detail, but a costly one. Long subject lines get cut off, especially on mobile. When that happens, prospects never finish reading—and never open.

Worse, some of their subject lines gave away the entire value proposition. Instead of building curiosity, they let the prospect disqualify the email before even clicking.

The takeaway here is simple:

• Keep subject lines short and clear

• Don’t give away the solution

• Focus on creating curiosity, not converting on the subject line alone

The Bigger Red Flag: No Replies

Once I moved into the email copy, I saw the second issue.

The emails were polished. Strong data. Solid logic.

But the messaging was too focused on the future state. The promise of where the prospect could go. Not the pain of where they are right now.

And here’s the thing:

Pain drives action faster than potential.

People are more likely to move away from discomfort than toward an abstract future desire.

This is where many well-meaning emails fall flat:

• They talk about revenue targets when the prospect is struggling with churn

• They highlight growth potential when the prospect is buried in operational problems

The more you align with your reader’s current pain, the more you earn their attention.

One more thing: never reveal your entire solution in the email.

If a prospect can fully understand your approach in 60 seconds, they’ll often disqualify themselves prematurely.

Instead:

• Tease the solution

• Show them you understand their problem

• Invite them to a call where you can walk them through the full fix

One Small Change That Moves the Needle

For this client, we made two simple changes:

• We rewrote the subject lines to spark curiosity, not sell

• We repositioned the email body to lead with pain, not promise

Sometimes you don’t need an entirely new sequence.

You need to remove the small friction points that quietly kill performance.

Want the Full List of Red Flags?

If you’re wondering what might be slowing down your own cold email results, this is where I’d start.

I created a Cold Email Red Flags Framework that covers the 17 most common mistakes we see in client and internal campaigns.

Inside, I break down:

• Which subtle copy patterns kill curiosity and replies

• How to fix deliverability traps before they cost you pipeline

• How to spot “good” emails that are still too safe to convert

• Why even well-researched emails sometimes land flat

• How to quickly pressure-test any outbound sequence before launch

→ Comment on this post and connect with me to get your copy.

We use this every week on our own campaigns and for every client we work with.

I think you’ll find it useful too.

Evangeline Gersich
Follow me on LinkedIn or Book a 1:1 Call